« Podcast improvements | Main | Magnatune Mobile »

February 15, 2011

Comments

joerg

Just for fun -- how does this correlate to the number of albums in each genre?

Spike Page

I am not surprised to see the classical music leading the pack. One thing about recordings of classical pieces is that they can be very good or very bad, depending on who is performing. But everything here is handpicked and good quality and a bargain for members. I only hope one day my father will join. He's crazy about classical.

Mary

Not surprised to see classical at the top. This is one of the main reasons I come to Magnatunes - because I can find fabulous medieval, renaissance, baroque, and classical recordings that one doesn't normally see at places like "iTunes". Keep up the good work, John. You've found some great artists and recordings!

Robin Snyder

John, I'm delighted that you're as much of a data geek as I am --- both figures are intriguing. (And as a classical-genre Magnatune musician, I'm pleased.)

market

I too am not surprised that Classical is the most popular, when I first was told about Magnatune that's what I came looking for but I now listen to lots of Ambient and electronica and have been inspired to start recording some. I like the fact that there is all sorts of stuff here that is really hard to find anywhere else........

market

Another way of looking at these figures is to total the Ambient, Electronica and New Age Categories........ which are closely related and overlap a fair bit..... 33%
Overall....... up there with Classical......

Turid

I really hope this won't lead to less rock, pop etc. in your catalogue! The reason for classical (and ambient, world etc) being so popular at magnatune.com is probably that you have promoted these genres heavily right from the start. People looking for rock might not know about you at all.

Rithban

I doubt the statistics will lead to less rock, etc.

These statistics are mere glimpse into the whole story. For a single example, how many submissions for the genres come in? If it's making money for the artists and Magnatune, why pull it? Especially since it costs hardly anything to leave it available.

It also may be a reflection of the audience, and the dynamics of the marketplace. Rock, dance, etc. has plenty of outlets. I have a good amount of music from small and self-published albums found through word of mouth and ordered off the 'Net.

It seems like it's gotten harder to find high-quality classical in the past decades. Magnatune's picks are consistently high quality. No shabby recordings of the state orchestra of former outer blovakia. Word gets around.

In truth, it's all speculation. Magnatune has high-quality albums regardless of the genre.

...

That's just a long-winded way to say my impression as a long-time customer is that Magnatune's expansion of offerings has been steady but hardly at break-neck speed. They're not following the path of other labels, which I respect. I heartily wish Magnatune best success for their own sake as well as the expansion of my own collection.

Win-win.

John

It strikes me that one issue that may skew these numbers is the relative breadth of categories. "Classical" is a very big tent, to the point that someone looking for Gregorian Chant and someone looking for post-Romantic French music will be looking in the same place. There is a much greater chronological and stylistic range in what you call classical music and what you call "hard rock," "electro rock," "electronica," etc.

John from Magnatune

As this thread is getting popular and lots of points are being made, I've created a followup thread here:
http://blogs.magnatune.com/buckman/2011/02/popular-genres-v2.html

with new charts based on the feedback above.

-john

Harald Korneliussen

Agree that the grouping favors classical music. "New Age" is a poor label: the music that is disdainfully described as "new age" by people who don't like it is a lot wider category than the music which is labeled such by the artists themselves. "Ambient" has less stigma attached, but is often indistinguishable.

This would also be an explanation for your finding in your followup post, John: I think people like the sound of "new age" music - but they don't think that they will like it, because isn't that about crystal healing and stuff? That people also like classical a good deal less than they think (but still quite a lot!), conversely, tells us that it's a prestigious label to have on your music.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.